The Best Organic Aftershave For Men

Benefits of Using an Aftershave

The best aftershave keeps your skin smooth and soft and helps you avoid dryness and itchiness. There was a time when men would experience burn practically after every shave. The shaving blade was metallic and cold and the whole procedure resembled a surgical procedure more than a cosmetic one. Well, guys, dark ages are gone! Nowadays things are much easier for men as there is a lot of natural and organic beauty products. Men get a tremendous amount of comfort after shaving by using specially designed and quality-made products.

But what is the best aftershave that you can get? When it comes to the best aftershave, you should take into consideration the smell, how much alcohol it has and your type of skin. The smell is important because this will be your fragrance for the day, so it needs to be something that you enjoy wearing. The fragrance can be lighter or stronger, fresh or with oriental accents. Depending on your type of skin, you can choose an aftershave that has more or fewer oils or alcohol in it.

Generally speaking, for oily or combined skin it is recommended to avoid oils unless they were created for your type of skin. When it comes to the alcohol in the best aftershave, you should make sure it doesn’t get your face skin very dry, otherwise, you might need to use it together with a moisturizing cream. Let us help you find the best aftershave for your skin type.

Our Selection of Best Aftershave

1. Castle Forbes Lavender Oil Aftershave Balm

There are many appreciative reviews written for the Castle Forbes Lavender Oil Aftershave Balm. People who use it often call it the best aftershave on the market or the Rolls Royce of aftershave balms, and this says a lot about the product! This balm has a lavender scent that will make you feel fresh and refreshed all day. There are no residues after applying the balm, certainly no greasy feeling on the face or hands.

The calming effect it has on the face is only equaled by the moisturizing properties, making it a great product for people with sensitive skin. The quality is superior to most other aftershave balms and it also has witch hazel in the formula. The witch hazel extract is well known for its antibacterial properties and can also help close pores. The formula is alcohol-free and contains lime essential oil. Suitable for all skin types.

thumbs up regular


  • Witch Hazel extract
  • Soothing aftershave
  • Alcohol-free
  • Paraben-free
thumbs down regular


  • Pricey

2. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

With key ingredients such as aloe leaf, chamomile, balm mint, sage, lavender and rosemary, this men’s grooming product is absolutely the best aftershave with cooling effects. Another benefit of the Post Shave Cooling Gel from Jack Black is that a dime-size amount is enough for an application. The smell is fantastic and many men reported back that their partners loved the smell.

There is no alcohol burn after using this cooling gel as it is alcohol-free and artificial fragrance-free. Actually, it will help you take care of your skin by soothing the skin and calming down the irritation caused by shaving. This formula contains natural ingredients that can fight bacteria that tend to accumulate at the level of the skin.

Make sure to apply just a small amount of product on your face. You can use the product on the face and neck after shaving. The Jack Black Post Shaving Cooling Gel could be a great idea for sunburnt skin too, so don’t hesitate to use it to calm irritated skin. This product is cruelty-free, dermatologically tested and the ingredients are all certified organic.

thumbs up regular


  • Organic certified ingredients
  • Calming shaved or sunburnt skin
  • Alcohol and Paraben-free
  • Cruelty-free
thumbs down regular


  • A bit sticky on the hands after application

3. Jovan Musk Aftershave Cologne

When wearing the Jovan Musk aftershave/ cologne you can expect women to come to ask you what is that smell, because apparently the fragrance is absolutely divine. The main difference between a regular aftershave and a cologne is the percentage of alcohol in the formula. The cologne is stronger and lasts longer compared to the regular aftershave. This is probably the reason why so many men prefer this product instead of other alternatives available on the market.

The woodsy notes and musk make for a manly product. At the same time, the carnation, Amalfi lemon, lime and pepper scents are also inviting and alluring. Packaging might vary for this classic product that you might develop a crush on! The product is longlasting, so you can enjoy it more, compared to similar items on the market. More than this, you will find yourself in a very select and high company after declaring your allegiance for this product!

thumbs up regular


  • Exquisite fragrance
  • Luxurious lotion
  • Leaves skin silky-smooth
  • Provides all-day hydration
thumbs down regular


  • Packaging might vary
  • Contains alcohol

4. Baxter of California Men’s After Shave Balm

If you are looking for the best aftershave that you will get to adore after the first time you use it, then the Men’s After Shave Balm from Baxter of California might be it. Men from all over the world have made this product their favorite aftershave due to its unique scent. It is very difficult not to like this product as it is incredibly soothing and leaves the skin moisturized. Also, you can forget about skin burns when you are using the Baxter of California Men’s After Shave Balm as it is alcohol-free and with skin calming properties. It helps prevent irritation while delivering a cooling sensation.

The texture of this aftershave balm is great and it’s the kind of product that a little goes a long way, so you can use it for a longer period of time compared with other aftershaves. With this aftershave moisturizer for men, your skin will be properly hydrated and protected from irritation and excessive dryness after shaving. The formula contains glycerin, aloe vera and allantoin, which have great benefits for sensitive skin, as well as tea tree oil, which helps prevent ingrown hair.

thumbs up regular


  • With aloe vera and allantoin
  • Relieves sensitivity & hydrates skin
  • Alcohol-free
  • Longlasting
thumbs down regular


  • Unique scent

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you really need aftershave?

If you don’t use aftershave, that is ok, but if you have sensitive skin or it gets easily irritated, then aftershave products can help you quite a bit.

Should you use an aftershave after electric razor?

Your skin is most sensitive after shaving and razor burns can still occur even with an electric razor. That is why applying a hydrating and soothing aftershave balm is the most beneficial thing you can do for your skin.

How long does the aftershave scent last?

There is a simple answer to this one. The cheaper ones usually last the least while a little more expensive ones tend to have a more lasting smell for anything up to 8 hours.

Avatar photo

About The Author

Elena D. is a passionate advocate for ethical consumer choices and sustainable living. With a deep commitment to clean, organic, and non-toxic products, Elena is on a mission to promote a healthier, planet-friendly lifestyle. Her expertise in non-toxic skincare and eco-conscious alternatives to traditional beauty products reflects her dedication to a more sustainable and compassionate world. Elena's goal is to empower readers to make informed choices that benefit both their well-being and the environment. Join her on the journey towards a cleaner, greener future.